Journal of the Whitefish Flyfishing and Philosophical Society
Articles
Inefficiency: The Key to Job Creation
Tom Frieze
02-20-2010
How to create new jobs, reduce our dependency on foreign oil, and save the planet.
A Christian Nation's Tipping Point
Bob Hodges
08-12-2009
From Under God to Above God
Free will and the Power of Prayer.
Andrew Frieze
08-12-2009
Do we have Free Will? If so, how can prayer have power. If prayer does have power, what boundaries are placed on our limited free will?
The Missing Link
Previous Question of The Month
08-04-2009
Does the alleged finding of the 'Missing Link' prove that humans are not the unique creation of God?
A Letter to Professor Gates
Joe Coco
08-04-2009
Racial healing in America won’t begin until you, a well educated and well connected professor, take responsibility for your own poor judgment.
Against National Health Care
Joe Coco
08-03-2009
It is no secret that the free market educates children much more efficiently than the government school system. Similarly, freer markets will deliver more efficient health care
The EPA's Suppression of Inconvenient Evidence
Tom Frieze
06-27-2009
Politics, rather than science, appears to be driving the agenda
Judge Sotomayor and the American Dream
Joe Coco
06-11-2009
Good parents have a greater impact on success than wealth, sex, or race.
Law vs. Moral Values
Walter Williams via Craig
05-06-2009
I can not help it. I just like a lot of what Mr. Williams has to say. Craig
Are You an "Extremist"?
Thomas Sowell
04-23-2009
Article by Thomas Sowell submitted for discussion by Craig FauntLeRoy
 

Judge Sotomayor and the American Dream

socrates

President Obama referred to Judge Sotomayor's journey from an East Bronx housing project to the federal appellate bench as "extraordinary." However, when one closely examines Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor's life it is revealed that she was blessed with America's greatest inequality: wonderful parents. While it is true her beginnings were materially humble, her success is not all that surprising when the sacrifices of her parents are taken into account. By having loving and strict parents who valued education, Judge Sotomayor was given advantages that millions of Americans of her generation never had.

Indeed, Ms. Sotomayor's father passed away from a heart attack when she was nine; however, he was married to Judge Sotomayor's mother when he died. Having parents who loved each other gave Judge Sotomayor an unfair edge over the other children in her neighborhood who were raised in broken homes. Although Judge Sotomayor's mother was a single mom, she was a model parent. Despite often working two jobs, she set the example for young Sonia to value education by taking night courses to advance her nursing degree. The elder Sotomayor lived frugally, choosing to raise her children in a small apartment in order to save money to send her kids to religious schools. Mother Sotomayor was strict. She always knew the whereabouts of her children, and they weren't allowed out of the house while she was at work. While other mothers were bringing home fashion magazines and gossip columns for reading material, Judge Sotomayor's mother was spending what little she had to purchase her children the only set of Encylopaedia Brittanica in their neighborhood. This made Judge Sotomayor (and her accomplished medical doctor brother, Juan) more competitive than other American children (of all races and sexes) whose parents chose not to have substantive reading materials available at home.

While the media and the current administration continue to spin Judge Sotomayor's story as being remarkable, conservative America understands the real reason she has achieved the American dream. By having decent parents, she was provided advantages her peers never had. Sonia Sotomayor's story demonstrates that the real culprit for inequality in 21st century America is not discrimination or lack of material abundance; its parents like Mr. and Mrs. Sotomayor who insist their children don't waste America's abundant opportunity.

Comments:

________________________________________________________________

Maybe the current administration is correct in portraying the Sotomayor story as remarkable. Today, it is remarkable to have this sort of upbringing. I'm not sure, however, that "conservative America" understands this any better than "liberal America". In fact, while I generally describe myself as conservative, I have known many "liberals" who embody the values you describe here much better than many conservative. Sometimes labels just get in the way.

Tom F.
6/13/2009 8:00:33 AM

________________________________________________________________

Add Your Comment:

Your Name: